To Tip or Not to Tip

There are actually rather more questions than that, but let's go back to the beginning. The practice of tipping long predates restaurants. When travelling and lodging in a private house it was customary to give money to the household servants. I think this was as a reward for additional services - shining shoes, pressing clothes and the like. These were originally known as vails.

For those who eat out, the concept of tipping isn't new, but these days it is coming under greater scrutiny, especially as restaurant prices inevitably soar. Why tip at all? What is the rationale for it? And who gets the dosh? As we'll see, in case you didn't know, things are very different in the UK and the States. As they are, indeed, in continental Europe and much of the rest of the world.

One might argue that a tip is a recognition and reward for exceptional service. Not usually the case here, is it? Where service charge is added to the bill (something with which I'm perfectly happy) I have to be very pissed off indeed to decline to pay it. Do remember that you are within your rights to do this, just as you are entitled to give more. But why do we do this? Well, think of a favourite mid level restaurant which you frequent regularly. How many of the servers were there last year, or even last month? But you know the owners. They are lovely people. You know they'll be considerate employers. But staff turnover is huge in the industry.

Isn't it just the case that being a waiter (and if lady thespians call themselves actors I too shall use the masculine noun) isn't seen as a proper job in this country. Honourable exceptions obviously, and more so in high end places, but so many of the people who bring your food are likely to be youngsters paying their way through Uni, or folk biding their time seeking that proper job. In Los Angeles where your server is likely to be impossibly glamorous, that desired proper job may be on the big or small screen.

Ah, back in the US of A. Give a tip of ten per cent there and be prepared for an earful. 15% might be regarded as a minimum, 20% perhaps nearer the norm. My understanding is that in some establishments waiting staff have no salary whatsoever, and are 100% dependent on tips. We on the other hand have minimum wage legislation.

What about Europe? In Spain there is a no tipping culture. In other countries I have, amazingly, seen a tip declined, or received with astonishment. In French cafes where each waiter is responsible for his own cash float, the norm was perhaps to leave the small change. The French word for a tip is a pourboire, literally for a drink.  I read somewhere that tip stood for To Insure Promptitude. Like most stories surrounding acronyms, that's a load of b******s. But going back to coin, one wonders whether the cashless society has changed our habits. A recent survey by a payment company called SumUp (no, I'd never heard of them either) suggests that the average tip in Britain has fallen by 51% since 2022. Mind you, the figures they cited were so tiny that I wonder what sort of establishments they were looking at.

Who else gets tips? Taxi drivers, though not in Edinburgh where the rates are about double those in Glasgow. Hairdressers, perhaps. Lawyers, less so. Though as one who acted for the licensed trade, my drinks cupboard was always well stocked with good whisky at Christmas. Just a shame that I don't touch the stuff.

Is it time to review our practice of giving gratuities? Maybe we have to ask why we tip. Or better still, why not? There is some legislation, about to be updated, to regulate what happens to your tip, but in an unfamiliar place I still like to ask waiting staff if it will indeed find its way to them. For once I finish an opinion piece with no views one way or the other. Apart that is from advising you to beware of the potential scam. The one where your bill includes a service charge, but the card machine gives you a handy helpful hint of how much extra to add.

But whether you tip or don't tip, please, please have respect for the hard working people who deliver your food and clear up after you, especially as we approach the horrors of festive dining. Tom Eats! operates under constant pressure except in December, when I avoid restaurants like the plague.

Leave a Comment